Spinning vs Baitcasting Reels
How spinning, baitcasting and spincast reels work, why spinning reels cast light lures easily and never backlash, why baitcasters give more control with heavier lures, line twist and how to avoid it, and what state agencies suggest for beginners.
The short version: a spinning reel casts light lures easily and can’t backlash, so it’s the usual first reel; a baitcaster gives more control and handles heavier lures, but needs practice to avoid overruns. This guide explains how each reel works, its strengths and problems, and what state agencies suggest, following Wikipedia’s fishing reel article, New York DEC and the Missouri Department of Conservation (MDC).
How each reel works (Wikipedia)
- Spinning reel (fixed spool): mounted below the rod. The spool doesn’t turn when you cast; line slides off its front edge in coils, and a bail rewinds it. It was developed to cast lures too light for conventional or baitcasting reels.
- Baitcasting reel: mounted above the rod. The spool turns as line leaves it and is geared so one turn of the handle turns the spool several times (usually four or more). It works with braid, fluorocarbon and monofilament.
- Spincast reel (closed face): a fixed spool hidden under a nose cone, usually above the rod. It avoids backlash and some of the line problems of spinning reels and can cast light baits, but casts shorter and holds less line. Wikipedia notes it remains a favourite for catfish fishing and for young beginners.
Spinning reels: strengths and problems
- No backlash: the spool doesn’t spin, so it can’t overrun and tangle (Wikipedia).
- Light lures: spinning reels cast light lures and baits that baitcasters struggle with.
- Line twist: spinning reels tend to twist line, from a spinning lure, from the bail, or from reeling while the line is under load. Wikipedia’s tips: pump the rod and reel in the slack rather than cranking against a heavy fish, and close the bail by hand after each cast. DEC adds that a small ball-bearing snap swivel helps with spinners and spoons.
- Loose loops: line can occasionally tangle under itself or jump off in loops, sometimes from overfilling the spool (Wikipedia).
- Line choice: spinning reels work best with fairly limp, flexible line (Wikipedia).
Baitcasters: strengths and problems
- Control and accuracy: because the spool turns with the line, a touch of the thumb stops a cast early or slows the lure in the air. Wikipedia says this is why many professional and bass anglers prefer them, and that they allow faster repeat casts even with heavier baits.
- Thumbing the spool also adds drag and helps set the hook (Wikipedia).
- Overrun (backlash): if the spool spins faster than line leaves it, line overruns and tangles. This is the main learning hurdle.
What agencies and anglers suggest
- Beginners and all-round bass: DEC’s “go-to” bass setup is a 6½-7-foot medium-action spinning rod with 8- to 10-pound monofilament; it calls a baitcasting rod with fluorocarbon or braid the more advanced option.
- Trout: DEC suggests light or ultralight spinning rods with 4- to 8-pound line, and MDC an ultralight spinning reel made for light line such as 4-pound test. MDC notes a basic spin-cast outfit works too.
- Heavier lures and cover: in a Bassmaster article on blade baits, one angler prefers baitcasting tackle for control and hooksets on big fish, and an Outdoor Life frog guide recommends a fast baitcasting reel to take up slack after a strike in heavy cover.
- Panfish and catfish: see our bluegill and channel catfish profiles; Wikipedia notes spincast reels remain a favourite for catfish and young beginners.
Our tackle by species tool suggests a setup for the fish you want.
Casting tips that apply to both
From MDC’s casting guide: grip the rod lightly, because holding it too tightly hurts both distance and accuracy; aim at a definite target; and to cast into a strong wind, release a little later for a lower trajectory. For distance, a longer rod matched to the lure helps, and keep the spool filled to capacity so line doesn’t drag on the spool lip.
Sources
- Wikipedia, Fishing reel. Read 28 October 2026.
- New York State DEC, Fishing for largemouth and smallmouth bass and Fishing for stream trout. Read 28 October 2026.
- Missouri Department of Conservation, Trout: fishing tips and Casting. Read 28 October 2026.
- Bassmaster and Outdoor Life articles linked above. Read 28 October 2026.
Recommended Gear on Amazon
- Spinning rod and reel combos - browse current options and reviews on Amazon.
- Baitcasting rod and reel combos - browse current options and reviews on Amazon.
- Braided fishing line - browse current options and reviews on Amazon.
As an Amazon Associate, we earn from qualifying purchases - at no extra cost to you. This helps us keep producing free, in-depth guides.
